فصلنامه علمی- پژوهشی اطلاعات جغرافیایی « سپهر»

فصلنامه علمی- پژوهشی اطلاعات جغرافیایی « سپهر»

ارزیابی توزیع فضایی پارکینگ‌های عمومی شهر کاشان و ارائه الگوی بهینه به منظوردسترسی مناسب شهروندان

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان
مهدی میرزا محمدی 1
ابوذر وفایی 2
سید احمد حسینی 3
1 کارشناس ارشد جغرافیا و برنامه ریزی شهری، دانشگاه کاشان، کاشان، ایران
2 استادیار گروه جغرافیا و اکوتوریسم، دانشگاه کاشان
3 استادیار گروه مهندسی شهرسازی، دانشگاه لرستان، لرستان، ایران
10.22131/sepehr.2024.2025812.3072
چکیده
پارکینگ‌ها از مهم‌ترین تأسیسات زیربنایی در شهر محسوب می‌شوند که نقش بسیار مهمی را در کاهش پارک حاشیه‌ای و ترافیک در معابر ایفا می‌کنند. کمبود پارکینگ‌های عمومی می‌تواند باعث بروز مشکلات مختلفی نظیر تلف شدن وقت شهروندان برای پیدا کردن فضای پارک مناسب، اشغال فضای معابر و به دنبال آن کاهش ظرفیت معبر و کاهش سرعت عبور و مرور و افزایش ترافیک شود. این پژوهش با هدف ارزیابی پارکینگ‌های موجود در شهر کاشان برای کارایی مناسب و همچنین ارائه یک الگوی بهینه به منظور مکان‌یابی پارکینگ‌ها انجام شده است . جمع‌آوری اطلاعات از طریق روش کتابخانه‌ای، نقشه‌های موجود و روش میدانی صورت گرفته است. به این منظور برای ارزیابی محدوده خدماتی پارکینگ‌های موجود از  مدل تحلیل شبکه و برای ارزیابی فضایی پارکینگ‌های موجود از روش آمار فضایی استفاده شده و درنهایت به منظور شناسایی مناطق مناسب ایجاد پارکینگ از مدلANP در سیستم اطلاعات جغرافیایی استفاده شده است. پس از آن بر اساس معیارهای مؤثر در مکان‌یابی پارکینگ عمومی در محیط ArcGIS فرایند مکان‌یابی صورت گرفته است. نتایج  این پژوهش نشان می‌دهد که مناطق مرکزی شهر کاشان در نزدیکی بافت تاریخی شهر شامل خیابان‌های اباذر چهارراه آیت‌الله کاشانی میدان دروازه دولت و میدان ۲۲ بهمن نسبت به سایر نقاط نیازمندی بیشتری به پارکینگ دارند. همچنین نتایج حاکی از آن است کاربری‌های جاذب سفر در مرکز کاشان تأثیر زیادی بر نحوه پراکندگی پارکینگ‌ها دارند، به نحوی که اکثر این  پارکینگ‌ها در منطقه تاریخی و در نزدیکی بازار کاشان مستقر شده‌اند. در نهایت از مساحت موردمطالعه 4.1 درصد( 19.244 هکتار) از محدوده موردمطالعه با کیفیت مناسب و 0.41(1.91هکتار) نامناسب برای احداث پارکینگ عمومی مشخص شد.
کلیدواژه‌ها
مکان‌یابی
پارکینگ عمومی
تحلیل شبکه
شهر کاشان
سیستم اطلاعات جغرافیایی

موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Evaluating the spatial distribution of public parking in Kashan and providing an optimal model for convenient access for citizens

نویسندگان English

Mehdi Mirzamohammadi 1
Aboozar Vafaei 2
Seyyed Ahmad Hosseini 3
1 Master of geography and urban planning, Kashan University, Kashan, Iran
2 Assistant professor, Department of geography and ecotourism, University of Kashan, Kashan, Iran
3 Assistant professor, Department of urban engineering, Lorestan University, Lorestan, Iran
چکیده English

Extended Abstract
   Introduction
Parking lots are considered to be one of the most important infrastructure facilities in the city, which play a very important role in reducing marginal parking and traffic on roads. A lack of public parking lots can lead to various problems such as citizens’ wasted time to find a suitable parking space, occupied road space, the reduced capacity of the road, and an increase in the speed of traffic. Besides, the availability of parking and its proper location will facilitate traffic congestion and reduce noise pollution. In this regard, Kashan is one of the urban areas that is influenced by the high population growth during the last six decades from 1335 to 1395 as a result of its intense physical development and its lack of coordination with all-round economic, social, cultural, and environmental development, especially in its lack of services and infrastructures. The city has many parking lots in its central part. In other words, the existence of travel-absorbing uses, especially in the city center, has created many problems in the field of transportation and traffic. The commercial, educational, and health uses have also made a large number of people to come and go on the streets in this part of the city during the day, which has resulted in and traffic and congestion. In addition, the existence of historical buildings in the city and the visit of tourists to these areas have added to this problem; therefore, the lack or inappropriateness of public parking spaces, as a means of attracting people and travel, leads to the lack of optimal access to parking and an increase in traffic in this part of the city. To this end, the current research aims to provide the optimal model for proper access of citizens to public parking lots by using the spatial analysis tools of the geographic information system while answering the following question: what is the spatial distribution of public parking lots in Kashan?
  Materials and Methods
The research is an applied one, and its method is descriptive-analytical. Information was collected through library studies in the first stage and field studies in the second stage. The field studies were used to supplement the information and update the existing maps, especially the map of the parking lots in the city of Kashan through observation. After collecting information, data and maps required for the research were created through formation of a database, the digitization of the maps; the tabular data were entered into the GIS database, and the aforementioned layers were converted into a standard format based on the indicators obtained from the background section of the research. For statistical analysis, AUTO CAD, ARC GIS, Super Decision, and other software were used. Afterwards, to evaluate high traffic areas for creating parking, kernel tests, hot spot, density distribution curve and network analysis were used.
  Results and Discussion
 The analysis of the hot and cold spots for determining the status of traffic clustering in each city block of Kashan showed that there were hot spots and more traffic in the central areas of Kashan than in the other parts of the city. A hot spot with a significant level of %99 was located in the central part of the city, which included the area of the old fabric of Kashan-- near Abazar Street, Doat Gate, and 22 Bahman Square-- and extends from the sides to Valiasr Street and Shahid Montazeri Street. Therefore, the amount of travel and traffic absorption coefficient was higher in the blocks that had a smaller area and a shorter distance to the city center. Besides, the investigation of the density of traffic points in different blocks of the city of Kashan, using the Kernel density estimation method, also showed that the centers near the entrance to the market--such as Abazar street in the east of the historical context of Kashan and the Ayatollah Kashani intersection--due to their proximity to travel-absorbing uses, had the highest traffic density in the city. Other traffic points were placed in the next ranks of traffic density. In order to locate the parking lot in Kashan, after calculating the weight of each of layers in the geographic information system and using Spatial Analysis and the Weighted overlay function, the weights obtained from the ANP model were assigned to each of the layers, and the layers were superimposed. Finally, two models and a proposed map for the construction of a parking lot were presented: the maximum amount of access for citizens in the first map and the optimal model with the highest efficiency and suitable access for citizens in the second map were the criteria of action.
 Conclusion
The results of the research have shown that the location of travel attraction centers in the central area of Kashan has a great role in the distribution and dispersion of parking lots in that area. It means that most of the parking lots in Kashan are located in the vicinity of travel attraction uses and near the old fabric of the city. However, these parking lots have not been able to achieve the necessary efficiency in reducing traffic and marginal parking. Therefore, to solve the problem of parking in Kashan and their optimal location, 10 relevant criteria were selected. After implementing the location process of two models, the maximum access of citizens to parking and the most optimal parking location model for the construction of public parking in Kashan were presented. In the most accessible pattern, %4.1 (19.244 hectares) of the studied area was determined to be of good quality and %0.41 (1.91) to be unsuitable. In the optimal pattern, %0.21 (1.182 hectares) was suitable and %12.09 (55.52) of the total area was found to be unsuitable.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Location
Public parking
Network Analysis
Kashan
Geographic Information System
1-AACPPO, (2017). Addis Ababa City Structure Plan. and Monitor Urban Land Change. Remote Sensing of Environment, 242, 111739.
2-Abbas Pourmarzbani, Karim., Baba Goli, Rezvan., Mojradi, Barat, Ameli, Alireza (2018): Location of urban parking using spatial information system and hierarchical analysis (case study: Babolsar). Research Journal of Transportation, 1 (15), 87-104. [in Persian].
3-Admasu, T.G., Jenberu, A.A., (2020). Urban planning implementation challenges in Arba Minch Town, Southern Ethiopia. Urban Forum 31 (4), 549–572. https://doi.org/ 10.1007/s12132-020-09393-6.
4-Alderete, M.V. (2021). Determinants of Smart City Commitment Among Citizens from a Middle City in Argentina. Smart Cities 2021, 4, 1-17, 1113–1129. https://doi.org/10.3390/smartcities4030059.
5-Alem, G., (2021). Urban plans and conflicting interests in sustainable cross-boundary land governance, the case of national urban and regional plans in Ethiopia. Sustain 13(6).https://doi.org/10.3390/su13063081.
6- Arnott, R., Inci, E., (2006). An integrated model of downtown parking and traffic congestion. J. Urban Econ. 60 (3), 418–442.
7-Arnott, R., Inci, E., Rowse, J., (2015). Downtown curbside parking capacity. J. Urban Econ. 86, 83–97.
8-Aziz, T., Van Cappellen, P., (2019). Comparative valuation of potential and realized ecosystem services in Southern Ontario, Canada. Environ. Sci. Policy 100, 105–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsci.2019.06.014.
9-Babaei M, Behzadi S. Spatial (2023). Data-Driven Traffic Flow Prediction Using Geographical Information System. Journal of Soft Computing in Civil Engineering. 2023;7(4):132-43.
10-Balac, M., Ciari, F., & Axhausen, K. W. (2017). Modeling the impact of parking price policy on free floating carsharing: Case study for Zurich, Switzerland. Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, 77, 207–225.
11-Barone, R. E., Giuffrè, T., Siniscalchi, S. M., Morgano, M. A., & Tesoriere, G. (2013). Architecture for parking management in smart cities. IET Intelligent Transport Systems, 8(5), 445–452.
12-Bates, J., (2014). Parking demand. Parking: Issues and Policies. Emerald, Bingley, pp. 57–86.
13-Behzadi S, Alesheikh AA, Poorazizi E. (2008). Developing a genetic algorithm to solve shortest path problem on a raster data model. J Appl Sci;8(18):3289-93.
14-Behzadi S, Alesheikh AA. (2013). Hospital site selection using a BDI agent model. International Journal of Geography and Geology. 2013;2(4):36-51.
15-Behzadi S, Hamoudzadeh A. (2021). Evaluation of effective factors on air pollution using optimized cellular automata: A case study of Tehran. Journal of Engineering Research. 2021.
16-Behzadi S, Mousavi Z, Norouzi E. (2019).  Mapping Historical WaterSupply Qanat Based On Fuzzy Method. An Application to the Isfahan Qanat (Isfahan, Iran). International Journal of Numerical Methods in Civil Engineering.;3(4):24-32.
17-Behzadi Sa. (2020). An intelligent location and state reorganization of traffic signal. Geodesy and Cartography. 2020;46(3):145-50.
18-Benenson, I., Martens, K., Birfir, S., (2008). Parkagent: An agent-based model of parking in the city. Comput. Environ. Urban Syst. 32 (6), 431–439.
19-Bram van, O., Li, Y., & Liu, S. (2015). Parking guidebook for Beijing. Retrieved from.
20-Brooke, S., Ison, S., Quddus, M., (2014). On-street parking search: Review and future research direction. Transport. Res. Rec.: J. Transpor. Res. Board 2469, 65–75.
21-Brueckner, J.K., Franco, S.F., (2017). Parking and urban form. Journal of Economic Geography 17 (1), 95–127.
22-Caggiani, L., Camporeale, R., Ottomanelli, M., Szeto, W.Y., (2018). A modeling framework for the dynamic management of free-floating bike-sharing systems. Transp. Res. Part C: Emerg. Technol. 87, 159–182. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trc.2018.01.001.
23-Cao, J., & Menendez, M. (2015). System dynamics of urban traffic based on its parkin grelated- states. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 81, 718–736. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trb.2015.07.018.
24-Cardullo, P., Kitchin, R. (2019). Being a „Citizen‟ in the Smart City: Up and Down the Scaffold of Smart Citizen Participation in Dublin, Ireland. GeoJournal 2019, 84, 1-13. doi: 10.1007/s10708-018-9845-8.
25-Chatrsimab Z, Alesheikh A, Vosoghi B, Behzadi S, Modiri M. (2020). Land Subsidence Modelling Using Particle Swarm Optimization Algorithm and Differential Interferometry Synthetic Aperture Radar. ECOPERSIA. 2020;8(2):77-87.
26-Chen, Y.W., Cheng, C.Y., Li, S.F., Yu, C.H., (2018). Location optimization for multiple types of charging stations for electric scooters. Appl. Soft Comp. J. 67, 519–528. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asoc.2018.02.038.
27-Chen, Z., Xu, Z., Zangui, M., Yin, Y., (2016). Analysis of advanced management of curbside parking. Transp. Res. Rec. 2567 (1), 57–66.
28-Dong, Y.-H., Peng, F.-L., Bao, Z.-H., & Qiao, Y.-K. (2021). Identification of the spatial distribution pattern and driving forces of underground parking space based on multi-source data: A case study of Fuzhou City in China. Sustainable Cities and Society,72,103084. doi:10.1016/j.scs.2021.103084.
29-Eskandari, M., & Nookabadi, A. S. (2018). Off-street parking facility location on urban transportation network considering multiple objectives: A case study of Isfahan (Iran). Transport, 33(4), 1067-1078.‏
30-European Commission, (2018). Fatal road accidents (per million inhabitants), 2018 ed. EUROSTAT, Brussels.
31-FAO, (2018). “Land-use planning basic knowledge detail,”pp.1–8, 2018,[Online].Available:http://www.fao.org/sustainable-forest-  management/toolbox/modules/land-use-planning/basic-knowledge/en/? Type=111.
32-G. Metternicht, (2017). “Global outlook working paper,” pp. 1–67, 2017.
33-Geroliminis, N., (2015). Cruising-for-parking in congested cities with an mfd representation. Econ. Transport. 4 (3), 156–165.
 34-Ghanbari, Hakimeh, Ahadnejad, Mohsen (2010): Investigating the problems caused by the lack of public parking spaces in urban management and how to locate them at the urban level using GIS, the second national scientific conference of geography students, pp. 11-16.[in Persian].
35-Ghasempoor Z, Behzadi S. (2021).Traffic Modeling and Prediction Using Basic Neural Network and Wavelet Neural Network Along with Traffic Optimization Using Genetic Algorithm, Particle Swarm, and Colonial Competition. Journal of Geomatics Science and Technology. 2021;10(3):147-63.
36-Ghasempoor Z, Behzadi S. (2022). Provide an Automated Webbased Platform for Collecting Traffic Data. Journal of Geomatics Science and Technology,12(1):171-86.
37-Ghashghaie S, Behzadi S. (2019).Spatial Statistics Analysis to Identify Hot Spots Using Accidental Event Calls Services. Journal of Statistical Research of Iran JSRI. 2019;16(1):121-41.
38-Ghorbin, Farhad, Alizadeh, Katayoun, Ahmadian, Mohammad Ali (2023): Locating urban public parking lots using ANP fuzzy logic model (Case study: Municipality of one district of Mashhad). Geographical Space, 23 (82), 247-227.[in Persian].
39-Griffiths, S., & Sovacool, B. (2020). Rethinking the future low-carbon city: Carbon neutrality, green design, and sustainability tensions in the making of Masdar City. Energy Research & Social Science, 62(101368), 1-9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss. 101368.
40- Guler, D., & Yomralioglu, T., (2018). “GIS and fuzzy AHP based area selection for electric vehicle charging stations”, International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, 42, 4.
41-Guo, S., and H. Zhao. 2015. “Optimal site selection of electric vehicle charging station by using fuzzy TOPSIS based on sustainability perspective.” Appl. Energy 158 (1): 390–402. https://doi.org/10.1016/j .apenergy. 08.082.
42-Gurjizadeh, Omid, Godarzi, Majid (2015): Investigating the spatial distribution of public parking in Yasouj city, the fourth scientific research conference of new horizons in the sciences of geography and architectural planning and urban planning in Iran.[in Persian].
43-Hilvert, O., Toledo, T., & Bekhor, S. (2012). Framework and model for parking decisions. Transportation Research Record, 2319(1), 30–38.
44-Hodkinson, G., Galal, H., & Martin, C. (2018). Circular Economy in Cities Evolving the model for a sustainable urban future. In Collaboration with PwC.
45-Inan, O.M., Inci, E., Robin Lindsey, C., (2019). Spillover parking. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological 125, 197–228.
46-Inci, E., (2015). A review of the economics of parking. Econ. Transport. 4 (1–2), 50–63.
47-Ioki K, Din NM, Ludwig R, James D, Hue SW, Johari SA, et al.  (2019). Supporting forest conservation through community-based land use planning and participatory GIS–lessons from Crocker Range Park, Malaysian Borneo. J Nat Conserv, 52:125740.
48-Ismaili, Fazallah., Haji Alizadeh, Javad., Nasiri Handeh Khale, Ismail., and Qaroni, Amirmasoud (2024): Location of multi-level parking by AHP method to reduce urban traffic (Case study: District 7 of Tehran), Road Quarterly, 32 (118), 276-265. [in Persian].
49-Jafarian H, Behzadi S.(2020). Evaluation of PM2. 5 emissions in Tehran by means of remote sensing and regression models. Pollution ,6(3):521-9.
50-Jalilzadeh A, Behzadi S, editors.  (2020). Flood Mapping and Estimation of Flood Water-Level Using Fuzzy Method and Remote Sensing Imagery (Case Study: Golestan Province, Iran). Forum Geografic; 2020: University of Craiova, Department of Geography.
51-Jelokhani -Niaraki, M., & Malczewski, J. (2015). A group multicriteria spatial decision support system for parking site selection problem: A case study. Land Use Policy , 42, 492 -508.
52-Jiang, H. (2020). Smart Urban Governance in the “Smart” era: Why is it Urgently Needed? Cities, 69,1-‌6.103004.‌ https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cities. 103004.
53-Karimi, Vahid., Ebadi, Hamid, Ahmadi, Salman (2007): Modeling the location of urban equipment using GIS with an emphasis on the location of multi-storey parking, National Geomatics Conference.[in Persian].
54-Kaviani, Yunus, Rahmani Fazli, Abdolreza (2011): Urban management and the challenge of locating public parking, 10th International Conference on Transportation and Traffic Engineering. [in Persian].
55-Kazazi Darani, S., Akbari Eslami, A., Jabbari, M., & Asefi, H. (2018). Parking lot site selection using a fuzzy AHP-TOPSIS framework in Tuyserkan, Iran. Journal of Urban Planning and Development, 144 (3), 04018022.‏
56-Kumar, A., & Anbanandam, R., (2020). “Location selection of multimodal freight terminal under STEEP sustainability”, Research in Transportation Business & Management, 100434.
57-Kunzmann, K.R. (2020). Smart Cities After Covid-19: Ten Narratives. Planinng. Rev, 56(2), 20–31. https://doi.org/10.1080/02513625.2020.1794120.
58-Litman, T., 2018. Parking management best practices. Routledge.
59-Liu, W., (2018). An equilibrium analysis of commuter parking in the era of autonomous vehicles. Transport. Res. Part C: Emerg. Technol. 92, 191–207.
60-Mahjoobi M, Behzadi S. (2022). Solar desalination site selection on the Caspian Sea coast using AHP and fuzzy logic methods. Modeling Earth Systems and Environment. 2022:1-9.
61-Manville, M., Shoup, D., (2018). People, Parking, and Cities. In: Parking and the City. Routledge, pp. 74–80.
62-Mattioli, G., Roberts, C., Steinberger, J. K., & Brown, A. (2020). The political economy of car dependence: A systems of provision approach. Energy Research & Social Science, 66, 101486. https:// doi.10.1016/j.erss. 101486.
63-Mirosław. Śmieszeka., Alexander. Lavrovb., Vasyl. Mateichyka., Jakub. Mościszewskia., Volodymyr. Fedorovc & Vasyl Yanovskyic (2023). Analysis of Traffic Noise Pollution Using Siemens Tecnomatix Plant Simulation, Transportation Research Procedia 74 (2023) 157–163,https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0.
64-Mohammadi, Jamal, Pourqioumi, Hossein, Zarei, Yaser (2012): Locating public parking in Kazeroon city, Scientific Research Quarterly of Iran Geographical Society, 10 (34), 213-232.[in Persian].
65-Mousavi Z, Behzadi S. (2019).  Geo-Portal Implementation with a Combined Approach of AHP and SWOT. International Journal of Natural Sciences Research. 2019;7(1):23-31.
66-Mousavi Z, Behzadi S. (2019).  Introducing an Appropriate Geoportal Structure for Managing Wildlife Location Data. International Journal of Natural Sciences Research. 2019;7(1):32-48.
67-Oecd (2019) ITF Transport Outlook (2019). OECD. https://doi.org/10.1787/transp_outlook-en-2019-en. Ortúzar, J.d.D., Willumsen, L.G., (2011). In: Modelling Transport. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester,UK.https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119993308.
68-ONU, World Population Prospects (2019). Highlights, United Nations Department for Economic and Social Affairs, New York (US)
69-Pasha A, Sorbi A, Behzadi S. (2018). Landslide risk assessment in Qazvin-Rasht quadrangle zone (North of Iran). Scientific Quarterly Journal of Geosciences. 2018;27(106):89-98.
70-Phillips, P.M., Jo˜ao, E., (2017). Land use planning and the ecosystem approach: an evaluation of case study planning frameworks against the Malawi Principles. Land Use Policy 68, 460–480. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2017.08.006.
71-Poorazizi E, Alesheikh A, Behzadi S.  (2008). Developing a mobile GIS for field geospatial data acquisition. J Appl Sci. 2008;8(18):3279- 83.
72-Prasertsri, N., & Sangpradid, S., (2020). “Parking Site Selection for Light Rail Stations in Muaeng District”, Khon Kaen, Thailand, Symmetry, 12(6), pp.1055-1056. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym12061055.
73-Prencipe,L.P., Colovic, A., De Bartolomeo, S., Caggiani, L., Ottomanelli, M., (2022). An efficiency indicator for micromobility safety assessment. In: IEEE International Conference on Environment and Electrical Engineering and IEEE Industrial and Commercial Power Systems Europe, EEEIC / I and CPS Europe. https://doi. org/10.1109/EEEIC/ICPSEurope54979. 9854627.
74-Reba, M. & Seto, K. C. (2020). A Systematic Review and Assessment of Algorithms to Detect, Characterize, and Monitor Urban Land Change. Remote Sensing of Environment, 242, 111739.
 75-Rustaei, Shahrivar., Qanbari, Hakimeh., Kazemizad, Shamsullah, Noorian, Rahimeh (2010), Providing the optimal model for locating neighborhood parking using AHP and GIS methods (case study: District 3 and 4 of Tabriz Municipality), Geography and Development Quarterly , 9 (23), 184-163. [in Persian].
  76-Sadeghi Darwazah, Saeed., Ghasemi, Ahmadreza., Rasouli Tilenoi, Neda and Shul, Abbas (2017): Locating mechanized parking with sustainable development approach (case study: Qom city), Quarterly of Economics and Urban Management, 6 (1), 111-127. [in Persian].
77-Selcuk Demir , Melih Basaraner , Alev Taskin Gumus, (2021). Selection of suitable parking lot sites in megacities: A case study for four districts of Istanbul, Land Use Policy, Volume 111, 105731,https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol. 10573.
78-Shafii Nikabadi, Mohsen, Hashemi, Fatemeh (2021): Locating multi-story parking with emphasis on sustainable urban development management, Road Quarterly, 29 (109), 123-140. [in Persian].
79-Shahab, S., Clinch, J.P., O’Neill, E., (2019). Impact-based planning evaluation: advancing normative criteria for policy analysis. Environ. Plan. B Urban Anal. City Sci. 46 (3), 534–550. https://doi.org/10.1177/2399808317720446.
80-Shin J-Ho, - H- Bae Jun, (2014). A study on smart parking guidance algorithm,-Transportation‌‌ Research Part C 44, pp. 299–317.
81-Shin, J-Ho _ H- Bae, Jun and J-Gon, Kim, (2018). Dynamic control of intelligent parking guidance using neural network Predictive control, Computers & Industrial Engineering 120, pp. 15–30.
82-Shoup, D. (1999). The trouble with minimum parking requirements. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 33(7-8), 549–574.
83-Shoup, D., (2018). Truth in Transportation Planning. In Parking and the City, Routledge.
84-Shoup, D.C., (2005). The high cost of free parking. American Planning Association, Chicago, Illinois.
85-Shoup, D.C., (2006). Cruising for parking. Transport Policy 13 (6), 479–486.
86-T. Xu, G. Han, X. Qi, J. Du, C. Lin, L. Shu,  (2020).  A hybrid machine learning model for demand prediction of edge-computing based bike sharing system using internet of things, IEEE Internet Things J.
87-UN. (2019). Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division. World Urbanization Prospects: The (2018). Revision (ST/ESA/SER.A/420). United Nations, New York.
88-Van Ommeren, J., Wentink, D., Dekkers, J., (2011). The real price of parking policy. J. Urban Econ. 70 (1), 25–31.
89-Workineh, N.A., (2021). Rezoning prior urban planning period for urban space development in Injibara Town, Amhara National Regional State, Ethiopia. Land Use Policy 109, 105702. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol. 105702.
90-Yang, H., Liu, W., Wang, X., & Zhang, X. (2013). On the morning commute problem with bottleneck congestion and parking space constraints. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 58, 106–118.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trb.2013.10.003.
91-You, P.S., Hsieh, Y.C., (2014). A hybrid heuristic approach to the problem of the location of vehicle charging stations. Comput. Ind. Eng. 70, 195–204.https://doi.org/ 10.1016/j.cie.2014.02.001.
92-Yun-Hao Dong,  Fang-Le Peng, Hu Li & Yan-Qing Me (2023). Spatial autocorrelation and spatial heterogeneity of underground parking space development in Chinese megacities based on multisource open data, Applied Geography.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeog.102897.
93-Żak, J., and S. Węgliński. 2014. “The selection of the logistics center location based on MCDM/a methodology.” Transp. Res. Procedia 3 (1): 555–564.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2014.10.034.
94-Zhang, X., Liu, W., Waller, S.T., Yin, Y., (2019). Modelling and managing the integrated morning-evening commuting and parking patterns under the fully autonomous vehicle environment. Transport. Res. Part B: Methodol. 128, 380–407.
95-Zhou, J., Wu, Y., Wu, C., He, F., Zhang, B., & Liu, F., (2020). “A geographical information system based multi-criteria decision-making approach for location analysis and evaluation of urban photovoltaic charging station: A case study in Beijing”, Energy Conversion and Management, 205, 112340.